Why Your Goals Are Blocking Promotion

In partnership with

Hey CS Pro,

You can be doing everything right on paper and still get passed over when the new senior CSM or team lead is announced. This episode and newsletter are about fixing that gap so your work is not just great for performance, but impossible to ignore for promotion.

Let us get straight into it.

But first, today’s sponsor

↓

From Hype to Production: Voice AI in 2025

Voice AI has crossed into production. Deepgram’s 2025 State of Voice AI Report with Opus Research quantifies how 400 senior leaders - many at $100M+ enterprises - are budgeting, shipping, and measuring results.

Adoption is near-universal (97%), budgets are rising (84%), yet only 21% are very satisfied with legacy agents. And that gap is the opportunity: using human-like agents that handle real tasks, reduce wait times, and lift CSAT.

Get benchmarks to compare your roadmap, the first use cases breaking through (customer service, order capture, task automation), and the capabilities that separate leaders from laggards - latency, accuracy, tooling, and integration. Use the findings to prioritize quick wins now and build a scalable plan for 2026.

Get the Full Report

Performance goals vs promotion goals

Most CS pros set goals that prove they can do their job well, not that they’re ready for the next role. Performance goals keep accounts healthy, but they rarely show business impact.

Performance goals sound like:

• Completed onboarding playbooks

• Responded to emails within 24 hours

• Held monthly check in calls

These are good for performance reviews but not promotion discussions. They show responsibility, not readiness.

Promotion goals sound different:

• Reduced time to value by 20% for enterprise accounts

• Influenced $100,000 in expansion pipeline

• Delivered ROI focused value reviews that secured executive sponsorship

These goals speak the language leadership uses in calibration meetings. They highlight revenue, risk, growth, and influence. When your goals shift from tasks to outcomes, your manager can finally advocate for you with confidence.

The mistakes holding you back

1️⃣ Setting generic goals without clear metrics

Goals like improving customer satisfaction or building stronger relationships feel positive but don’t show measurable impact. If your manager can’t quantify your progress, they can’t champion you.

Tie your goals to something trackable, just like you would in a customer success plan.

2️⃣ Waiting for your manager to define your goals

A generic list of goals for every CSM will keep you performing, not progressing. If your manager leaves mid-cycle or priorities shift, your promotion narrative disappears with them.

You need to own that narrative, not outsource it.

3️⃣ Not documenting progress throughout the year

This is the biggest barrier. Most CS pros wait until midyear or end of year reviews to remember twelve months of work in one sitting. That is impossible.

Your brain is not a CRM. If you are not capturing revenue influence, wins, adoption shifts, or stakeholder expansion as you go, your review becomes a guessing game.

The people who get promoted are rarely the ones who work the hardest. They are the ones who can clearly show what their hard work produced.

Promotion goal framework

1️⃣ Align your goals to business outcomes

Look at what your company’s leadership actually tracks. Usually that means net revenue retention, gross revenue retention, adoption, risk reduction, and customer growth.

Tie each major goal to at least one of those outcomes.

Swap tasks for measurable impact. For example:

Instead of complete ten onboarding calls each month, use shorten onboarding time to value from thirty days to twenty.

Instead of hold monthly check ins, use secure multithreaded executive alignment across eighty percent of my book.

2️⃣ Choose your North Star goal

Pick the one result that would make you feel confident asking for the next title. This should be measurable, visible, and clearly linked to the level you want next.

Examples:

• For senior CSM: own $500,000 in influenceable revenue and lead one scalable process improvement

• For VP track: create predictable revenue tracking and forecast $200,000 per quarter per CSM

Your North Star becomes the filter for every decision you make across the year.

3️⃣ Track, package, and pitch

This is where most CS pros fall short. You cannot rely on memory when review season rolls around.

You need to track your wins regularly, package them into business friendly language, and pitch them confidently during your review.

This is exactly why I created the Customer Success Promotion Tracker. It gives you a ready made structure to

• log your weekly and monthly wins

• quantify your revenue influence

• document adoption impact

• organise stakeholder expansion

• translate your work into executive-ready language

It becomes your personal revenue report for promotion season. Instead of scrambling at the end of the year, you have a clean, running record of every impact you’ve made, making your promotion pitch 10x easier.

Weekly Challenge

Choose one existing goal and rewrite it using this framework.

Ask yourself:

• Does it tie to a business outcome?

• Is it measurable?

• Does it show readiness for the next level?

Log it in your tracker, whether that’s a spreadsheet, Notion doc, or the Promotion Tracker. If you’re feeling bold, send the updated version to your manager as a signal that you’re thinking more strategically this year.

That one shift can completely change how you’re seen for the next promotion cycle.

Check out the full podcast for more tips:

👉 CS Promotion Tracker
Helps you collect wins, quantify revenue influence, and show your manager why you are ready for the next step.

👉Train AI to Be Your Revenue-Generating Customer Success Co-Pilot
Shows you how to train AI to handle busy work so you can focus on real value.

👉The Value Storytelling Handbook for Customer Success
Teaches you how to turn product usage into business impact that lands with execs.

👉The Objection Handling Guidebook for Customer Success
Gives you repeatable scripts for tough churn conversations.

I hope you enjoyed this week’s newsletter.

If you have any questions or suggestions, please feel free to contact us.

Cheers to your CS success,

Anika

PS - RevUP Academy is currently full. Don't miss your shot at next time! Get the strategies, playbooks, and build your confidence into a revenue-generating CS Pro. Join the VIP Waitlist today to be first notified when the doors open again.